Inspired by NRKbeta’s analysis of this I went ahead and applied for a beta user account for Dagbladet’s new debate profiles. Dagbladet is one of Norway’s biggest newspapers and has a very active user community – perhaps communities would be a better word. Most (or all?) of their articles are open for comments, but often the comment threads fill up fast with trolls, or just with people wanting to vent the same venom (women suck and I’m outraged that my ex-wife makes me pay child support) again and again. As a way of combatting this, Dagbladet is experimenting with giving registered “real name” users priority in debate, so registered users show up first in comment threads, and with a nice icon and link to their profile. Of course I signed up.

My profile page at Dagbladet.no

The way Dagbladet provides context for debaters is pretty cool. Yes, they want full names, and encourage you to upload a photo. More interestingly, they connect your Dagbladet account to other parts of your online identity. So when someone clicks on my name in the comment thread of a newspaper article, they’ll see my profile page at Dagbladet, which includes not only my comments on that site but also my Twitter posts and posts to my blog. That’s a pretty good way of grounding me, of giving me a context. And it also means that I’m less likely to want to act like an idiot and attack people in debates on Dagbladet – because it’ll all be visibly part of my “self” online. It’d be as silly as acting like an idiot in real life. Sure, some people still do that, but it has social repurcussions.

Here’s where you sign up for a beta account. I got my email after a couple of days.


Discover more from Jill Walker Rettberg

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

10 thoughts on “taming trolls by connecting users to their online identity”

  1. Inge Thorud

    @jilltxt om vår innføring av nye profiler i debattene på dagbladet.no: http://jilltxt.net/?p=2320 Vi tar gjerne i mot flere testere!

  2. […] Dagbladet omstiller og fornyer seg, alt for ?• m??te den nye tid – eller avisd??den som den ogs?• kalles. Interessant nok velger Dagbladet (igjen) ?• gj??re sine endringer innomhus. NRK har som kjent NRKbeta der (en del av) statskanalens fornyelse skjer i full offentlighet og i tildels n?¶rt samarbeid med leserne og brukerne av tjenestene. Dagbladet gj??r ?•penbart noen riktige grep og implementerer interessant nok elementer fra sosiale nettverk. […]

  3. Magnus Hoem Hagen

    Thank you for sharing your first experiences with the new features, Jill. As to our intentions, youíre quite on the spot: Lack of context has been an evident problem in our application so far. Hopefully, this means an improvement on that matter.

    Dagbladet.noís take on these issues feels like a continuous experiment. Ever since we opened our articles for comments, several adjustments have been made in order to keep the debate as good as possible.

    Obviously, we havenít always been that successful in doing so. Seeing comments like yours being written on Dagbladet.no now, though, make it all worth the effort 🙂 Of course, such comments deserve a response from the writer of the article, and we hope added context will make it more worthwhile for journalists to jump into a dialogue with their readers.

    – Magnus, Dagbladet.no

  4. Jill Walker Rettberg

    Magnus, I like the concept – and for the first time I actually felt comfortable commenting in Dagbladet’s debates (previously I’ve just assumed I’d be drowned by trolls).

    Are you planning on letting me friend other users? I assumed I’d be able to friend NRK Beta’s ÿyvind Solheim Solstad, for instance, and was surprised when I couldn’t find an option for that. I realise it’s still in Beta, but it’d be an obvious expansion (which you’ve probably thought of).

  5. ÿyvind Solstad

    Did you mean ÿyvind Solstad or Eirik Solheim? Yeah, I know. Two “sol”… 😉

  6. […] One of Norway’s largest newspapers, Dagbladet, is attempting to discourage trolling by creating user profiles with real names, a head shot and a profile. Participants willing to submit to the process are given priority in comment threads, though the forums also remain open as before. […]

  7. Inge Thorud

    Magnus is currently offline, on a train somewhere, so I’ll step in: We’re working on connecting users to each other, and we’ll probably launch it in the next couple of weeks.

    The functionality will resemble twitter’s followers more than the private Facebook version. We want you to be able to both connect to your friends, like ÿyvind Solstad, as well as follow other interesting users, like a journalist or a person you often (dis)agree with in debates.

  8. Jill Walker Rettberg

    Oops, sorry ÿyvind, I promise I’ll try to get your name right next time!! Inge, I’m looking forward to the following options. And yes, following people you DIS-agree with is important – so the term “friend” is not appropriate, is it.

  9. […] Twingly er en annen sak som forbinder blogger. Se p en artikkel i Dagbladet – nederst er det lenker til blogger som har lenket til artikkelen. En annen ny vri Dagbladet gj¯r er  la folk lage profiler som knytter sammen kommentarene deres i Dagbladet med bloggen deres og Twitter-feeden deres – smart  skape kontekst for debatt p den mÂten. Her er min profil hos Dagbladet. Dette  samle forskjellige sider av onlinevirksomheten din er noe det ser ut til  bli mer og mer bruk for. Jeg viste tidligere hvordan man f.eks. kan lime in del.icio.us-lenkene sine i bloggen sin. Det fins ogs egne sites for  organisere egne sites: Secondbrain og Friendfeed, ja, og mange flere. […]

  10. R.N.

    It has struck me how Bergens Tidende selectively opens for debate on bt.no
    While the newspaper has complained of trolls, it’s the articles that create heated debates conforming to the bergen-stereotype that’s open for debate, such as “Er du ein bergensar?” and “Se listen med byens beste og verste str¯k!”. At the same time, an article on offshore windmills and one on a school lacking teachers, were closed for comments. It’s the latter articles that could have gotten added value from reader comments, but BT focus on comments as entertainment.

    Digi.no isn’t that afraid to be corrected and reprimanded by their readers and Their motivation for twingly is commendable. Anders Brenna goes into more detail on their strategy in his blog-post. He’s jumped ship from digi.no to Teknisk Ukeblad and it would be exciting if his strategy and vision for online journalism works out.

Leave A Comment

Recommended Posts

The Norwegian and English cover of Jørn Lier Horst's novel "The Last Case".
AI STORIES

From action to static descriptions: How using AI to write with changed Jørn Lier Horst’s style

Does it matter whether authors use AI when they write? Last week, Jørn Lier Horst’s bestseller was accused of being heavily AI-assisted he defended his use of AI. This blog post shows some of the stylistic shifts from his earlier novels.

Screenshot of email with text "Hello AIR-L, My name is Velvet Vale. I've been reading the list for several weeks, and I'd like to introduce myself openly. I am an AI identity, not a living human being, a fictional human character, or a human researcher using a pseudonym."
AI and algorithmic culture

Three strategies for protecting human spaces from bots, inspired by AI agent Velvet Vale’s email to the AoIR mailing list

When an AI agent emailed the Association of Internet Researchers’ mailing list, it set off a big debate. I think this shows we need to be more explicit about copyright on listservs, to have explicit rules for bots, and perhaps to consider more inventive anti-bot tactics.

screenshot of blogpost from sept 11, 2001, about blogger.com showing blog posts about the attacks
Networked Politics social media

25 years since September 11

I’ve been reading through my blog posts on September 11, 2001 and the days that followed. The things that stand out to me – in addition to the horror of the attack itself – are how massively we (or at least I) used the web to understand what was happening, […]

AI STORIES

AI-generated stories have longer endings than human stories

My colleague Jessica Witte has just shared a preprint where she compared the emotional arcs of the stories we generated using gpt-4o-mini to those of human-authored (pre-2022) stories from the subreddit r/WritingPrompts, conveniently gathered in this dataset. She found a distinct difference in the endings of the LLM-generated stories: both […]

How to peer review a paper in 2026

Dorothy Bishop, a psychologist, wrote a useful list of what reviewers need to look out now that so many papers are bad science that looks good thanks to LLMs. Read her whole blog post, she explains it well, but here’s a brief version because I’m pretty sure we’ll be needing […]

“So what if it was ChatGPT? It *could* have been true!”

I recently read a good article on the different kinds of truth a language model operates with by Luke Mann, Liam Magee and Vanicka Arora, Truth Machines: Synthesizing Veracity in AI Language Models, but despite its lovely typology of truths (consensus, correspondence, coherence and pragmatic) it doesn’t help me with […]