So here’s a google search to show students: try searching the Chinese version and the US version of Google for “Tiananmen”. As in Tiananmen Square. Remember? If you’re in China, the government would rather you didn’t. (via Stayfree, Pen to Paper and others)


Discover more from Jill Walker Rettberg

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

7 thoughts on “stark difference

  1. Martin

    Try “sweatshops” too. Then ask yourself what reason a government which is supposedly
    opposed to capitalism could possibly have for not allowing that word to go through
    a search engine.

  2. Jill

    Huh? The results look the same?

  3. Elin

    Actually, my google searches give completely different results here in Bergen than they did in Boston – although I didn’t try anything political yet… just silly stuff like slipcovers etc.

  4. Martin

    Weird. I got no results in the Chinese one, and bunches of pictures in the US one.

  5. Gro

    hi jill, this is out of topic, but you are here:
    http://www.fistfulofeuros.net
    good luck!

  6. Francois Lachance

    Quite apart from the who seen what question, there is the interesting question of what happens to rankings. In a combined search of two or more regaional search engines, how would the results be ranked? What would a combined Norwegian and Canadian view of the materials avaiable look like? What struck me in the two different set of images was the geopolitical considerations of what gets published where (i.e. what struck me in the US-based google.com was the militaristic impression — a military power tends to spot military might or people with military training and the military as part of their lives see weaponary as part of the scenary and a way of reading the historic record). For some reason (French spelling?) I did a search with an alternate spelling… tiannamen … and behold a much more mixed set of images.

  7. Claus

    > Weird. I got no results in the Chinese one …

    Naturally – because Google submitted to censorship in Mainland China.

    > Actually, my google searches give completely different results here in Bergen

    Here in Germany, I couldn’t invoke google.cn at all. I sent a question to Google Germany, but didn’t get an answer, yet. Via the links in thsi post it worked. (I wonder if I’ll be getting one *at all*!)

Leave A Comment

Recommended Posts

AI copyediting: how Paperpal butchered my paper on AI-generated writing

This morning I received the copy-edited version of a paper I recently submitted to a journal. This is always cause for celebration, another step towards publication accomplished! But this time the copy-editor wasn’t human, it was an AI. We have undertaken a light text edit using the tool Paperpal Preflight; […]