Kunstkritikk.no has a blog about art criticism and blogging, written by Leif Magne Tangen and full of interesting links and thoughts about what art critics blogging, or criticism in blogs, might mean. (Yes, it was finding this blog with its link to my blog that gave me the kick in the butt to actually write about Farteins hage, for instance.)

Among other things, Leif Magne links to a discussion about The State of Criticism where some of the participants have blamed blogging for the demise of traditional art criticism, though to be fair that original article also points out many positive aspects of “the diffusion of power”. Tyler Green has some interesting points, in particular noting out the myth of the golden age:

  1. There never was a golden age of art critics when the world moved in lock-step with what art critics said is good and bought/museo-attended accordingly. Never was. And every story I’ve read seems to start with the belief that such a time existed. The whole question of “influence” is a canard. What is “influence” anyway? (And don’t gimme Clem — at times he acted as much like a production-determining/controlling/advising dealer as anything else.)
  2. On blogs and art: There is a historical precedent for the role blogs play in the art world. What we do is quite similar to the role pamphleteers/’zines/etc. have played in conversations about art in the last 120 years. Guillaume Apollinaire, to name one example, wrote in tabloid handouts, sometimes doing no more than listing the artists who were in shows he’d seen. Freebie tabloids = blogs. Apollinaire’s columns were often sandwiched betwen patent medicine ads. Kind of reminds me of Google Ads for erotic art posters I see ’round the ‘net.

I found out about Alexandre Dumas’ personal newspaper last week. Thomas Edison’s diaries are another example of blog-like things famous people did in the olden days.

Has anyone written a pre-history of blogs yet?


Discover more from Jill Walker Rettberg

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

3 thoughts on “art criticism and blogging”

  1. Angela Thomas

    There’s a great article by Jose van Dijk called “Composing the Self:
    Of Diaries and Lifelogs” here:
    http://journal.fibreculture.org/issue3/issue3_vandijck.html
    that explores the relationship between “traditional” diaries and blogs.
    It may be slightly different to what you’re after but the references point to other possible historical diary writing. I’ve used this article a lot with teachers when doing
    a “what’s the same and what’s new?” about this social/discursive practice kind of discussion.

  2. thomas m

    This is probably a bit on the side of what you are both writing about and asking for, however it’s a really intereseting read!

  3. jill/txt » the prehistory of blogs

    […] Other items in the prehistory of blogs include Alexandre Dumas’ personal newspaper, Thomas Edison’s diaries and art criticism in pamphlets and zines. Filed under:General, blog theorising — Jill @ 10:07 [ ] […]

Leave A Comment

Recommended Posts

screenshot of blogpost from sept 11, 2001, about blogger.com showing blog posts about the attacks
Networked Politics social media

25 years since September 11

I’ve been reading through my blog posts on September 11, 2001 and the days that followed. The things that stand out to me – in addition to the horror of the attack itself – are how massively we (or at least I) used the web to understand what was happening, […]

AI STORIES

AI-generated stories have longer endings than human stories

My colleague Jessica Witte has just shared a preprint where she compared the emotional arcs of the stories we generated using gpt-4o-mini to those of human-authored (pre-2022) stories from the subreddit r/WritingPrompts, conveniently gathered in this dataset. She found a distinct difference in the endings of the LLM-generated stories: both […]

How to peer review a paper in 2026

Dorothy Bishop, a psychologist, wrote a useful list of what reviewers need to look out now that so many papers are bad science that looks good thanks to LLMs. Read her whole blog post, she explains it well, but here’s a brief version because I’m pretty sure we’ll be needing […]

“So what if it was ChatGPT? It *could* have been true!”

I recently read a good article on the different kinds of truth a language model operates with by Luke Mann, Liam Magee and Vanicka Arora, Truth Machines: Synthesizing Veracity in AI Language Models, but despite its lovely typology of truths (consensus, correspondence, coherence and pragmatic) it doesn’t help me with […]

AI STORIES

AI shimmer and sparkle

I have this hunch that sparkles and glow and shimmer are somehow a point in the latent spaces of LLMs that have more connections than you would expect. Perhaps their connotation to magic and to the unknown matches some of the mystique of genAI? Or perhaps these words are used […]