There are a lot of interesting theory papers being published on AI these days, and I don’t just want to read them all, I want to discuss them with people. So I whipped up a list of papers I’d like to read and invited people, thinking it’d probably just be 2-3 people in the CDN meeting room. But then people were saying they’d like to join online, so I made a zoom link, and for our first session, which was dedicated to discussing Mark Coeckelbergh’s paper “Technofascism: AI, Big Tech, and the new authoritarianism,” we had about a dozen people in person and another dozen online. It was great!

I had worried it would be difficult to have an actual discussion in the hybrid format, but it worked just fine. Several people had reading suggestions, and when Anja Salzman showed the group some German book recommendations, the online people self-organized a German-language online reading group in the chat – I hope they report back to those of us who are less proficient in German. Here are some of the reading recommendations from Anja and other participants:

Several people thought that fascism and AI could both have been defined more clearly. “I agreed with everything in the article,” one participant said, “but I kept wishing he would make the argument more convincing,” and several people nodded in response. I actually didn’t notice a lack of clarity when reading the article, and found it well written. I’ve been reading up on fascism in the last year, so recognized most of the material discussed, but found it a useful summary that I think would be a good introduction. And as someone pointed out, it’s not like there’s one singular definition of fascism, it’s a fuzzy concept.

Dom, who happens to have written a book about myth, pointed out that myth is also not very clearly defined. But the treatment of myth in the paper is one of the ideas I found really interesting. Coeckelbergh argues that while classical fascism centers on a myth of a glorious past that must be reborn, technofascism puts emphasis on myths of the future, and in particular the myth of AI being about to be capable of almost anything. I’ve not thought of the connection between AI hype and fascism before, because the classic definitions of fascism usually emphasise the past. Another angle, which Dianna pointed out was missing from the article, is the way AI is being used to create a (fake) mythic past. Ida called AI-imagery “speculative fiction,” which is another good insight.

Another critique of the article was its emphasis on fascism alone. Various people pointed out that an alternate origin story could have been told, for example emphasising the cyberlibertarianism of the United States, or authoritarianism in general. A couple of people commented that the Marxist perspective seemed almost to be being avoided – Fuchs was mentioned, but barely, and what about cannibal capitalism, someone asked. Others were pleased that Erich Fromm was included. And several, like me, were particularly interested in Coeckelbergh’s emphasis on how AI is used to manipulate emotion, often through intimacy, and its connection to aesthetics.

Towards the end of the paper, Coeckelberg writes of the need to tell stories about the potential good uses of AI. But most of his paper is about the bad effects of technology. “What about #metoo? Or the Epstein files?” someone asked. The same technology can be used to tear down oppressive systems and build community. We need to not only be telling and retelling those stories as well as the bad ones, we should also work to enable more of these good uses of technology.

A lot more was said, of course. And I’m looking forwards to our next session! It’ll be on March 10th from 12 noon until 13:00 Bergen time, and we are reading Ryan Heuser’s paper “Generative Aesthetics: On Formal Stuckness in AI Verse“, published in the Journal of Cultural Analytics. Either join us in person in the glass house at CDN at the University of Bergen, or you can sign up for the Zoom.


Discover more from Jill Walker Rettberg

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave A Comment

Recommended Posts

The Norwegian and English cover of Jørn Lier Horst's novel "The Last Case".
AI STORIES

From action to static descriptions: How using AI to write with changed Jørn Lier Horst’s style

Does it matter whether authors use AI when they write? Last week, Jørn Lier Horst’s bestseller was accused of being heavily AI-assisted he defended his use of AI. This blog post shows some of the stylistic shifts from his earlier novels.

Screenshot of email with text "Hello AIR-L, My name is Velvet Vale. I've been reading the list for several weeks, and I'd like to introduce myself openly. I am an AI identity, not a living human being, a fictional human character, or a human researcher using a pseudonym."
AI and algorithmic culture

Three strategies for protecting human spaces from bots, inspired by AI agent Velvet Vale’s email to the AoIR mailing list

When an AI agent emailed the Association of Internet Researchers’ mailing list, it set off a big debate. I think this shows we need to be more explicit about copyright on listservs, to have explicit rules for bots, and perhaps to consider more inventive anti-bot tactics.

screenshot of blogpost from sept 11, 2001, about blogger.com showing blog posts about the attacks
Networked Politics social media

25 years since September 11

I’ve been reading through my blog posts on September 11, 2001 and the days that followed. The things that stand out to me – in addition to the horror of the attack itself – are how massively we (or at least I) used the web to understand what was happening, […]

AI STORIES

AI-generated stories have longer endings than human stories

My colleague Jessica Witte has just shared a preprint where she compared the emotional arcs of the stories we generated using gpt-4o-mini to those of human-authored (pre-2022) stories from the subreddit r/WritingPrompts, conveniently gathered in this dataset. She found a distinct difference in the endings of the LLM-generated stories: both […]

How to peer review a paper in 2026

Dorothy Bishop, a psychologist, wrote a useful list of what reviewers need to look out now that so many papers are bad science that looks good thanks to LLMs. Read her whole blog post, she explains it well, but here’s a brief version because I’m pretty sure we’ll be needing […]

“So what if it was ChatGPT? It *could* have been true!”

I recently read a good article on the different kinds of truth a language model operates with by Luke Mann, Liam Magee and Vanicka Arora, Truth Machines: Synthesizing Veracity in AI Language Models, but despite its lovely typology of truths (consensus, correspondence, coherence and pragmatic) it doesn’t help me with […]